November 11, 2022

Where does your Agency Management System fall short?

Nearly every agency owner asks me, “Which management system do you recommend? Because mine sucks.” Let's break down the reasons why.

Share icon

Breaking down agency management systems.

If you're in the business of commercial insurance, you know the challenges of agency management software. You're looking for a single platform that increases efficiency and improves client retention.

Unfortunately, agency management software routinely falls short. Every agency owner asks me, “Which management system do you recommend?...Because mine sucks.”  The interfaces are outdated, the outages are frequent, and you often have time to go to lunch and come back before your page loads. There is legacy infrastructure, updates are infrequent, and client engagement is minimal. All too often, a sizable investment winds up underutilized, as your team is unable to fully embrace all the features that come with it.

What should insurance agency management software offer?

Whichever AMS you choose, it should provide a package of services that helps your agency operate more efficiently and generate true ROI. Let's start by breaking down key elements we think agency management software should deliver, and help you decide if yours fails to meet expectations.

Table Stakes—Customer, Contact & Policy Information (Bonus for Document Management)

At its core, an AMS is a place to store customer information, contact information and policy information.  A reasonable addition is the ability to store customer or policy related documents (e.g. insurance applications, policy documents, signed authorizations)

On top of this basic functionality you’ll need a few management features like reporting and activity logging.  

Reporting is easier said than done, of course.  Simple reporting could include things like a list of clients with active policies or a list of clients in a certain location or with a certain type of policy.  More advanced reporting would allow you to benchmark your clients using things like industry & revenue.  Good luck finding anything like that. 

Finally, activity logging is crucial for E&O coverage.  You need a record of all of your client communications to protect yourself in the event of a claim.  

Value Added Capabilities—Sales & Accounting

A GOOD management system will also help you handle key business functions like sales & accounting.  

From a sales perspective, you need an easy way to track opportunities and forecast revenue.  But insurance sales are different then traditional sales in that you have both new opportunities and renewal opportunities.  Simple automation can help to create the renewal opportunities and set their close dates and values.  

A great Customer Relationship Management tool can be a defining component part of your AMS. Yet, too often, they leave users underwhelmed and fail to generate the kind of positive client experience that increases retention.

The CRM tools should also integrate easily with other platforms, whether it's application and renewal software like Broker Budda, your email suite, graphing tools, reporting applications, or your calendar. Your AMS is meant to be an engine for your agency, and not operate as a silo.

And don’t forget your accounting department.  Insurance accounting is complicated as hell.  Each carrier has their own commission schedule.  Each producer has their own commission schedule.  Some invoices are sent by and paid to the carrier and you have to invoice them for your commission.  Some are sent by and paid to the agency and you have to deduct your commission and send the difference to the carrier.  You need some way to track all this and manage your books.  It’s hard!  

Interaction with Clients and Carriers

A GREAT management system will interface well with organizations outside of yours, in particular your carrier partners and your clients.  

One key feature for carrier interfaces is the ability to download policy data directly from the carrier.  This keeps your systems in sync with carrier systems so you can be in the best position to support your clients.  Bonus if the AMS also supports carrier upload (e.g. submitting data for quotes)

On the client side, a great AMS will have an intuitive interface for clients to access policy data, apply for coverage, request changes and file claims.  It should also have a simple way to initiate and log outbound client communications as well as their responses (see earlier note about E&O).

Data: Reporting, APIs, Partnerships and Third-Party Software

The BEST management systems will have modern APIs allowing you to read and write information and support for integration with 3rd party products like:

  • Xero, Quickbooks
  • Gmail, Outlook
  • Salesforce/Hubspot/etc.
  • Broker Buddha

Sadly, no AMS does this well today.  

In a business built around data, insurance agencies need accurate reporting and access to their own data. Trouble is, collecting all that information to create reports can be time-consuming and woefully inefficient.

An AMS needs to do more than simply be a place to input data—it needs to help insurance professionals compile all of it in a way that is useful. Too often, data is collected but organized in a way that makes it difficult to use.

If your AMS is not delivering reports or tools that make your operations more efficient, it is underperforming. And frankly, that's probably most Agency Management Systems.

Secure and Accessible Data

Many legacy Agency Management Systems are woefully dated, and have failed to evolved as the world around them has changed. Not only is the software often painful to use, many of the major players hold your agency data hostage. Data ownership is a huge issue.

And without an open platform, you may not even have access to your own agency information. It's why so many agencies, after investing in an AMS, wind up turning to a solution such as Salesforce as a workaround for their data.

What's more, maintaining the security of data is a constant, evolving effort. The companies that offer your AMS need to provide safeguards that protect it now, and in the future.

Don't simply assume the largest or most established insurance AMS is the best choice for your agency. If it's an outdated, largely back-office platform, you can find yourself regretting your investment.

Workflow Management

Finally, every agency needs a workflow management solution of some kind.  The more people in your agency, the more important it is to have workflows defined and tracking using collaboration tools.  What’s the next step in renewing a policy?  Whose is responsible?  When does it need to be completed?  Having all of these things locked down go a long way to running an effective & efficient agency.  Management systems with workflow tools integrated are the true holy grail for an agency.  


The promise of technology is always greater efficiency and higher productivity. To achieve both, an AMS should eliminate high-touch, manual entry tasks, and replace them with automation that saves time and eliminates human error.

A powerful AMS should create a set-it-and-forget-it mindset. Or more accurately, set-it-so-you-never-forget-it. Automated email reminders should be easy to establish, so messages are sent directly to agency personnel when important dates are looming.

Too often, an AMS still forces agents and brokers to input data manually. As much as possible, the AMS should capture available information automatically and move it into the appropriate fields.

Which AMS should you choose?

The right technology is a true difference maker in the agency business. Too often, firms find the performance of their AMS underwhelming.

That's unfortunate, since the COVID-19 era has only increased the need for this industry to embrace technology. Remote work forces, fewer in-person meetings, stressed-out clients who want a seamless customer experience—the challenges created by the pandemic have made the need to fully digitize operations even more pressing.

If you are considering an Agency Management System, ask plenty of questions about it. If you're already operating with one, can you improve it by integrating it with other software? Remember, the whole reason to have an AMS is to increase the efficiency of your team, enhance the customer experience, and generate more customer loyalty.

Does yours deliver? Or is it a dud?

Goodbye time wasted.
Hello optimization with Broker Buddha

blue check mark
Online forms
blue check mark
Efficient use of time
blue check mark
Automated Reminders

Never miss an episode

Subscribe here to be notified when a new podcast episode goes live.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Broker Buddha logo
Replaces email, paper,fax, spreadsheets and PDFs, simplifying the submission process
Featured Articles

You might also like

Nov 10, 2022
Our first time at the CIAB 2022 Insurance Leadership Forum

We recently attended the Council of Insurance Agents and Brokers (CIAB)'s Insurance Leadership Forum and met with leading insurance agency executives from across the country—and the globe—during the five-day event.

read now
Aug 19, 2022
The Best Broker Buddha Offsite Yet

This past week was super special. On Wednesday and Thursday last week, the entire Broker Buddha team participated in a company offsite. There was a lot to celebrate.

read now
Dec 22, 2020
Four ways being a dinosaur will cost your insurance agency.

Not only do dinosaurs become extinct, they're expensive. Here are four ways dinosaur tendencies cost money at commercial lines insurance agencies.

read now
Dec 2, 2020
Insurance, software, change, surprises, shock, comedy.

Surprising your customers, even when it's positive and transformational change, is no laughing matter.

read now
Aug 20, 2020
Four Ways Insurance Agencies are Managing Through the Pandemic

In this unprecedented era, find out some of the ways smart commercial insurance agencies are working to serve clients now and position themselves for the future.

read now
Jun 23, 2020
Listening. Learning. Changing.

CEO Jason Keck shares his thoughts on social justice in this country, the discussions inside our company, and how he plans to be a part of positive change.

read now
May 15, 2020
What's our sales process?

Chief Revenue Officer Sean Harvey offers his thoughts on the sales process during this current time, and why the most tech-enabled agencies are positioned for success.

read now
May 12, 2020
A virtual conversation with BrokerTech Ventures.

In February, we were selected for the Accelerator program at BrokerTech Ventures (BTV). We caught up with Susan Hatten, COO at BTV, and John Jackovin, Executive Director of the BTV Accelerator.

read now
Apr 9, 2020
Find out what these commercial insurance professionals said.

CEO Jason Keck hosted a free webinar last week with some top commercial insurance professionals. Watch it to find out how your colleagues are managing during these challenging times.

read now
Apr 7, 2020
Our COVID-19 update.

It's an unprecedented situation. Here's what we're doing to ensure that Broker Buddha continues to serve its customers and its community.

read now
Mar 24, 2020
Build strong broker-client relationships. Even now.

As commercial insurance agencies work to serve clients during the coronavirus crisis, the brokers with the right tools are building better relationships by handling more requests efficiently.

read now
Mar 3, 2020
Commercial Insurance and Tech Not So Different After All

I came to Broker Buddha from the tech world and had lots of preconceived notions about the world of insurance. Turns out most of them were wrong.

read now
Feb 27, 2020
BrokerTech Ventures Made Us a First-Round Draft Pick

BrokerTech Ventures, backed by some of the leading independent agencies in the United States, chose us for their InsurTech 2020 Accelerator following our presentation during their Selection Series program. Things are moving fast—it starts on March 2nd.

read now
Feb 5, 2020
Travelers Quarter and Rising Commercial Insurance Prices

Our take on Travelers latest quarter and how price pressure could help commercial insurance agencies in the year ahead.

read now
Jan 28, 2020
Team Grows at Broker Buddha.

We're adding new users and features every day—and growing our development team to continue making our platform as powerful as possible.

read now
Jan 8, 2020
Commercial insurance and the pace of change.

Commercial insurance agencies can be slow to change. The renewal and application process is one example. My question: why?

read now
Nov 27, 2019
Happy Thanksgiving.

We'll tell you about our online smart forms for commercial insurance agencies later. Today, let's talk about Thanksgiving.

read now
Nov 7, 2019
Commercial insurance: your next clients will have new expectations.

In the future, more of your clients will be millennials. And they'll expect technology to make buying insurance easier.

read now
Oct 3, 2019
We're Expanding our Customer Success Team.

We're growing and adding great people.

read now
A buddha linear icon


Book a demo